Egg Salad Bell Pepper Boats

20 min Prep 10 min Cook 2 Servings
Egg Salad Bell Pepper Boats

Watch how it’s made

Every step in 1:04 — from the ingredients to the finished dish.

Eggs spent thirty years being treated as something to ration, and the advice has moved on. The 2015 US Dietary Guidelines removed the specific daily cholesterol limit, because the evidence that dietary cholesterol drives blood cholesterol in most people turned out to be weaker than assumed.

The picture for diabetes specifically is less settled, and it is worth being straight about that rather than declaring the question closed. What is not in dispute is that an egg carries 6 grams of high-quality protein for under a gram of carbohydrate.

What the guidance actually says now

Current dietary guidance treats eggs as part of a healthy eating pattern rather than something to limit by number. Some observational studies in people with diabetes have found associations with higher intake, and the findings are inconsistent.

The practical position most dietitians take is that eggs are fine in the context of an otherwise good diet, and that what accompanies them usually matters more than the egg. This snack is eggs with vegetables; the version that concerns anyone is eggs with bacon, sausage and buttered white toast.

If you have been told something specific by your own care team, that instruction beats anything written here.

How to boil them so they peel

Lower them into water that is already boiling rather than starting them cold. The sudden heat sets the outer white against the shell membrane and the shell comes away in large pieces.

Ten minutes for a firm yolk, then straight into ice water for five. The cold shock contracts the egg slightly away from the shell and stops the yolk developing the grey ring.

Older eggs peel more easily than very fresh ones. It is one of the few times the older carton is the better choice.

Yogurt instead of mayonnaise

The eggs already bring fat with them, which is why egg salad made entirely with mayonnaise is so rich. Greek yogurt with a teaspoon of Dijon keeps the creaminess and adds protein.

A single teaspoon of mayonnaise stirred in alongside gets you the flavour people are looking for at a cost of about 4 grams of fat across the whole batch.

Bell peppers rather than bread

Quartered lengthways, a bell pepper makes a natural boat with a curve that holds filling. Two slices of bread carry around 30 grams of carbohydrate; the peppers carry 6 for the whole snack, and bring vitamin C and fiber with it.

Red peppers are sweeter and more expensive; green are sharper and cheaper. Both work and a mix looks better.

Chop the eggs, do not mash them

Roughly chopped, you get distinct pieces of white and yolk and a texture worth eating. Mashed with a fork it becomes a paste.

Fold the dressing through gently at the end rather than mixing hard.

Ingredients

  • 6 eggs
  • 3 bell peppers, quartered lengthways and seeded
  • 1/3 cup plain Greek yogurt
  • 1 tsp mayonnaise (optional)
  • 1 tsp Dijon mustard
  • 2 celery stalks, finely diced
  • 2 tbsp red onion, finely diced
  • 2 tbsp fresh chives, snipped
  • 1 tbsp lemon juice
  • Paprika to finish
  • Salt and black pepper

Instructions

  1. Lower the eggs into already boiling water and cook 10 minutes.
  2. Transfer them straight to ice water and leave 5 minutes, then peel.
  3. Mix the Greek yogurt with the Dijon, lemon juice, mayonnaise if using, salt and pepper.
  4. Chop the eggs roughly, keeping distinct pieces rather than mashing.
  5. Fold the eggs through the dressing with the celery, red onion and most of the chives.
  6. Spoon into the bell pepper quarters, scatter the remaining chives and dust with paprika.

Nutrition (per serving)

285 kcal
Calories
11 g
Carbs
22 g
Protein
17 g
Fat
3 g
Fiber

Tips

Lower the eggs into water that is already boiling rather than starting them from cold. The sudden heat sets the outer white against the shell membrane, and the shell then comes away in large pieces instead of taking half the white with it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Current dietary guidance treats them as part of a healthy pattern and the specific daily cholesterol limit was removed in 2015. Some studies in people with diabetes have found associations with higher intake and the evidence is inconsistent. If your own care team has given you specific advice, follow that.

Usually because they went into cold water, or they are very fresh. Boiling water first and an ice bath afterwards fixes most of it.

The egg salad keeps two days refrigerated. Fill the peppers within an hour of eating.

You can. Two tablespoons adds about 20 grams of fat across the batch and removes the protein the yogurt contributes.

References

Where the general guidance on this page comes from. Figures are population-level recommendations, not advice for your own situation.

Glucose Smart Kitchen Team

We are a small team of home cooks and keen readers of nutrition guidance, not doctors or dietitians. We write the site we wanted when diabetes first came into our own lives: recipes that work on a weeknight, and plain explanations of the advice published by bodies like the ADA and the CDC.

Join Our Community

Get new recipes, health tips, and meal plans delivered to your inbox every week.